Pony Island: main story about 2.5 hours; story with some extras about 3.4 hours; 100% completion about 4.3 hours. These are IGDB player-submitted averages from 6 submissions, not a deadline or a prediction of your pace.
Source: IGDB player submissions
Community playtime data is not available for Pony Island yet.
Game Tales keeps what happened between you and a game in one Tale you can keep building.